Durbin Regulation Ruling: Appeals Court Overturns Lower Court Decision

21 Mar

 Today the District of Columbia Court of Appeals upheld the Federal Reserve Board’s regulations interpreting the Durbin Amendment, and in so doing reversed the lower court’s decision invalidating those rules.  Last July, Judge Leon of the U.S. District Court concluded that the Board’s regulations violated the Durbin Amendment statute’s plain language.  Today the Court of Appeals disagreed, holding that the Board’s rules are a reasonable construction of the law. 

The court noted that it reviewed the Board’s interpretation of the law directly, according no deference to the lower court’s ruling.  In an opinion that is a marked departure from the lower court’s combative tone, today’s opinion logically analyzes each of the arguments advocated by the merchants and by the Federal Reserve Board, concluding that the Board’s interpretation of the Durbin Amendment language should stand.

The court remanded back to the Board one aspect of the Durbin regulation, requiring an explanation of the Board’s interpretation of the fraud prevention adjustment.  In the meanwhile, the existing regulation remains in place.

Thus, unless and until today’s decision is appealed to the Supreme Court, both the interchange fee and the anti-exclusivity aspects of the current regulation govern.

 –Holli Targan, Partner, Jaffe, Raitt, Heuer & Weiss, P.C.

 

Holli Targan

Attorney & Partner

htargan@jaffelaw.com

Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply

Why ask?